为何法治概念应包含“基本正义要求”
Basic Justice Demand: The Conceptual Condition of the Rule of Law
-
摘要: 法治仅具备形式原则并不足够,因为几乎任何人类社会以法律统治的模式都要求一定的形式原则,但并非任何具备形式原则的法律统治都能称之为"法治"。政治关系和法律属性上的道德性决定法治需至少有追求实质法治的可能性,任何一种实质法治的可能性需建立在法体系满足"基本正义要求"基础上。因此"基本正义要求"是包含了形式原则的法律统治得以称之为法治的概念条件,其中根本人权与自由是"基本正义要求"的核心成分。但包含"基本正义要求"的法治不应等同于实质法治,它仅构成任何一种实质法治的前提条件。Abstract: Formal principles alone do not amount to the rule of law, since almost any type of ruling by law calls for certain formal principles, yet not any such kind of ruling can be recognized as “the rule of law”. Political relations and law is essentially moral, which means that the rule of law is morally sensitive that it is at least able to achieve the rule of good law, and the prerequisite of any version of the rule of good law has to satisfy “basic justice demand”. Hence, “basic justice demand” is the conceptual prerequisite of the rule of law, while fundamental human rights and freedom is the key exemplar of which. However, the rule of law is not rendered as the rule of good law, it is merely the precondition of the rule of good law.
-
Key words:
- the rule of law /
- formal principles /
- basic justice demand /
- the rule of good law
-

计量
- 文章访问数: 12
- HTML全文浏览量: 2