动物意识的规范维度——后期维特根斯坦论动物心灵及其启示

王晓阳

PDF
Cite
Share

facebook

twitter

google

linkedin

June 2026

Article Contents

Citation: WANG Xiaoyang. The Normative Dimension of Animal Consciousness——The Later Wittgenstein on Animal Minds and Its Contemporary Implications[J]. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(6): 16-27. shu

The Normative Dimension of Animal Consciousness——The Later Wittgenstein on Animal Minds and Its Contemporary Implications

WANG Xiaoyang

Abstract

Contemporary research on animal consciousness is often caught in an epistemological predicament over whether the evidence is sufficient,a predicament rooted in a categorial displacement between two notions of “criteria”.Recent work,represented by Birch and colleagues,has developed a set of criteria for assessing animal sentience and uses them as empirical indicators for inferring inner states;the “criteria” Wittgenstein discusses in the Philosophical Investigations and his later manuscripts are,by contrast,grammatical conditions constitutive of the use of psychological predicates,revealing the normative dimension of animal consciousness.Failing to distinguish clearly between these two kinds of criteria,contemporary debate locks a question that properly belongs to grammar into a framework of evidence-accumulation and is thereby driven to an impasse.The controversy over octopus pain is a clear case in point.The later Wittgenstein's legacy on animal minds points to a reorientation of inquiry:from asking whether there is sufficient evidence that animals possess inner states to examining which animal behaviors,within our form of life,already constitute criteria for the use of psychological predicates.This reorientation not only helps contemporary research on animal consciousness move beyond the predicament just described but also offers illuminating conceptual resources for current debates on AI consciousness.
- Wittgenstein,
- animal minds,
- animal consciousness,
- criteria and evidence,
- philosophy of mind
References
Access
1. [1]
  XU Xiangdong . Consciousness and The Moral Status of AI Agents. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(8): 5-15.
2. [2]
  HE Jun . Confucius's Paradigm Shaping of Chinese Philosophy. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(8): 56-69.
3. [3]
  NI Liangkang . The Philosophy of History of “New Idealism” after Hegel: Neo-Hegelianism. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 12-22.
4. [4]
  CHEN Yinchi , WU Siqi . Interaction and Integration between Buddhist and Daoist Hagiographies in Medieval China. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 157-169.
5. [5]
  YING Qi . Hegel's Conception of Reconciliation and the Quarrel of the Ancients and the Moderns. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 23-31.
6. [6]
  QIN Zhongliang . Historical Views and Historical Facts: The Evolution of Perceptions of Fanzhen since the Song Dynasty. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 181-194.
7. [7]
  SHEN Yifei . Theoretical Genealogies of the Emotional Economy and the Chinese Context. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 129-142.
8. [8]
  ZHANG Jun , FANG Hongsheng . Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations and Economic Growth. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(8): 70-90.
9. [9]
  ZHOU Mujun . Between Theory and Empirical Facts: Habermas and the Sociological Debate on the Public Sphere. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(8): 157-170.
10. [10]
  LU Mingjun . Simulacra, Pattern Recognition, and Computational Formalism——Reflections on the Application of AI in Artistic Practice and Art History Research. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(8): 41-55.
11. [11]
  ZHAO Lin , ZHANG Boyu , LIANG Hua . The Relationship Between Monopoly and Innovation in Information Product Markets——A Growth Network Perspective. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 64-76.
12. [12]
  LIAO Han . Popular Religion and the Formation of Local Culture——Research on the Belief in Ge Xian'gong in Northeastern Jiangxi since the Song and Yuan Dynasties. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 195-205.
13. [13]
  RAN Gaoran . The Evolution and Game of Property Systems——On the Paradigm Choice for Data Property. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(7): 117-128.
14. [14]
  LI Ming , XU Haiqi , XU Changtuo . A Statistical Framework and Measurement Results for Public Finance Investing in People. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(8): 91-105.
15. [15]
  YANG Rui . Five Planet Conjunctions: Reinterpretation of the Celestial Phenomenon in 1007. Academic Monthly, 2026, 58(8): 207-216.

Get Citation

PDF

XML

Entire Issue PDF

Article Metrics

Article views: 473 Times PDF downloads: 2 Times Cited by: 0 Times

Metrics

PDF Downloads(2)
Abstract views(473)
HTML views(105)

Latest
Most Read
Most Cited

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

1.
沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院沈阳 110142

The Normative Dimension of Animal Consciousness——The Later Wittgenstein on Animal Minds and Its Contemporary Implications

WANG Xiaoyang

Abstract: Contemporary research on animal consciousness is often caught in an epistemological predicament over whether the evidence is sufficient,a predicament rooted in a categorial displacement between two notions of “criteria”.Recent work,represented by Birch and colleagues,has developed a set of criteria for assessing animal sentience and uses them as empirical indicators for inferring inner states;the “criteria” Wittgenstein discusses in the Philosophical Investigations and his later manuscripts are,by contrast,grammatical conditions constitutive of the use of psychological predicates,revealing the normative dimension of animal consciousness.Failing to distinguish clearly between these two kinds of criteria,contemporary debate locks a question that properly belongs to grammar into a framework of evidence-accumulation and is thereby driven to an impasse.The controversy over octopus pain is a clear case in point.The later Wittgenstein's legacy on animal minds points to a reorientation of inquiry:from asking whether there is sufficient evidence that animals possess inner states to examining which animal behaviors,within our form of life,already constitute criteria for the use of psychological predicates.This reorientation not only helps contemporary research on animal consciousness move beyond the predicament just described but also offers illuminating conceptual resources for current debates on AI consciousness.

HTML

Relative (15)

DownLoad: Full-Size Img PowerPoint

Return

The Normative Dimension of Animal Consciousness——The Later Wittgenstein on Animal Minds and Its Contemporary Implications

Abstract

References

Access

Article Metrics

Metrics

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

The Normative Dimension of Animal Consciousness——The Later Wittgenstein on Animal Minds and Its Contemporary Implications

HTML

目录