儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开

杨国荣

English

引用本文: 杨国荣. 儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开[J]. 学术月刊, 2018, 50(03): 33-41. shu

Citation: . Confucianism and Pragmatism: The Intrinsic Philosophical Theme and Their Diverse Developments[J]. Academic Monthly, 2018, 50(03): 33-41. shu

儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开

杨国荣

Confucianism and Pragmatism: The Intrinsic Philosophical Theme and Their Diverse Developments

摘要: 人如何存在、如何生存，是儒学与实用主义共同关注的问题。儒学要求将天道落实于人的存在过程，实用主义则主张从形而上的超验世界，转向人的生存过程。在关注人之“在”的同时，儒学与实用主义又表现出不同的特点。由理性、精神层面的关注，儒学同时追求以人格提升为指向的完美的生活；由感性、经验的注重，实用主义则更为关切与生物有机体生存相关的有效的生活。人的存在具体展开于多样的情境，但儒学由精神的关切而同时承诺本体及广义之知，实用主义则由本于经验而注目于情境中的特定问题本身，并在将概念工具化的同时趋向于融知于行。生活的完美性和生活的有效性都包含价值内涵，儒学与实用主义由此关注认识的评价之维，但儒学以是非之辩接纳了认知，实用主义则趋向于以评价消解认知。要而言之，儒学与实用主义既展示了相近的哲学旨趣，又表现出不同的思想进路。
Abstract: How human being exists and lives is the common problem of concern in Confucianism and pragmatism. Confucianism demands bringing the way of Nature to bear upon the process of the human’s being, while pragmatism insists on turning from the transcendent world of metaphysics to the human’s process of existing. While focusing on human existence, Confucianism and pragmatism present different characteristics: while Confucianism focuses more on the reason and spirit in the being of humans, pragmatism focuses more on the empirical and sensible aspects of the process of living. Due to focusing on reason and spirit, Confucianism simultaneously seeks the elevation of human character and the perfection of life; due to focusing on sensibility and experience, pragmatism also concerns itself with effective living in connection with the survival of the biological organism. The spiritual and empirical dimensions of existence both concern the concrete situations of the individual’s being as well as the actions that unfold in situations, but Confucianism, due to being concerned with the spiritual dimension, remains committed to the original substance and knowing in the broader sense, while pragmatism, due to being rooted in experience and focusing on specific problems in situations, instrumentalizes concepts and simultaneously dissolves knowledge in practice. The perfection of life and the effectiveness of life both involve the significance of value, so Confucianism and pragmatism both focus on the evaluative dimension of knowing, but Confucianism incorporates cognition through the debate over the distinction between right and wrong, whereas pragmatism tends to eliminate cognition through evaluation
1. [1]
  倪梁康 . 黑格尔之后的“新观念论”历史哲学：新黑格尔主义. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 12-22.
2. [2]
  贺磊 . 康德“物自身问题”的视角主义审思——兼评牟宗三与李明辉的阐释. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(3): 31-40.
3. [3]
  鲁明军 . 拟像、模式识别与计算形式主义——反思AI在艺术创作与艺术史研究中的运用. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(8): 41-55.
4. [4]
  高建平 . 关于美的哲学思考. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(1): 170-179.
5. [5]
  雷磊 . 数字司法的方法论立场：功能主义抑或规范主义?. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(1): 108-119.
6. [6]
  何俊 . 孔子对中国哲学的范式形塑. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(8): 56-69.
7. [7]
  王刚 . “继往开来、融贯中西”：从胡先骕的师友网络看“学衡派”的文化旨趣. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 206-216.
8. [8]
  李玉栓 . 明代僧诗风貌的新变及其成因. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 170-180.
9. [9]
  林尚立 . 建构原创性理论的中国使命及其方法论基础. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 5-11.
10. [10]
  王晓阳 . 动物意识的规范维度——后期维特根斯坦论动物心灵及其启示. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(6): 16-27.
11. [11]
  詹玲 . 当代中国科幻小说的青春叙事及其诗学精神流变. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(3): 166-175.
12. [12]
  马春花 , 张靖宜 . “科幻渴望性别”:《珊瑚岛上的死光》及其在新时期的改编. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(3): 176-184.
13. [13]
  徐向东 . 意识与智能体的道德地位. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(8): 5-15.
14. [14]
  秦中亮 . 史观与史实：宋代以降藩镇观的嬗变. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 181-194.
15. [15]
  张军 , 方红生 . 政府间财政关系与经济增长. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(8): 70-90.
16. [16]
  陈引驰 , 吴思奇 . 中古道佛传记的交涉与互融. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 157-169.
17. [17]
  沈奕斐 . 情感经济的理论谱系与中国语境. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 129-142.
18. [18]
  应奇 . 黑格尔的和解概念与古今之争问题. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(7): 23-31.
19. [19]
  刘闯 , 刘思嘉 . 概念工程：理解心灵与智能的可能方式. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(1): 11-19.
20. [20]
  周沐君 . 在理论与经验事实之间：哈贝马斯与公共领域研究的社会学论辩. 学术月刊, 2026, 58(8): 157-170.

点击查看大图

计量

PDF下载量: 42
文章访问数: 4745
HTML全文浏览量: 458

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

1.
沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院沈阳 110142

儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开

杨国荣

摘要: 人如何存在、如何生存，是儒学与实用主义共同关注的问题。儒学要求将天道落实于人的存在过程，实用主义则主张从形而上的超验世界，转向人的生存过程。在关注人之“在”的同时，儒学与实用主义又表现出不同的特点。由理性、精神层面的关注，儒学同时追求以人格提升为指向的完美的生活；由感性、经验的注重，实用主义则更为关切与生物有机体生存相关的有效的生活。人的存在具体展开于多样的情境，但儒学由精神的关切而同时承诺本体及广义之知，实用主义则由本于经验而注目于情境中的特定问题本身，并在将概念工具化的同时趋向于融知于行。生活的完美性和生活的有效性都包含价值内涵，儒学与实用主义由此关注认识的评价之维，但儒学以是非之辩接纳了认知，实用主义则趋向于以评价消解认知。要而言之，儒学与实用主义既展示了相近的哲学旨趣，又表现出不同的思想进路。

English Abstract

Confucianism and Pragmatism: The Intrinsic Philosophical Theme and Their Diverse Developments

Abstract: How human being exists and lives is the common problem of concern in Confucianism and pragmatism. Confucianism demands bringing the way of Nature to bear upon the process of the human’s being, while pragmatism insists on turning from the transcendent world of metaphysics to the human’s process of existing. While focusing on human existence, Confucianism and pragmatism present different characteristics: while Confucianism focuses more on the reason and spirit in the being of humans, pragmatism focuses more on the empirical and sensible aspects of the process of living. Due to focusing on reason and spirit, Confucianism simultaneously seeks the elevation of human character and the perfection of life; due to focusing on sensibility and experience, pragmatism also concerns itself with effective living in connection with the survival of the biological organism. The spiritual and empirical dimensions of existence both concern the concrete situations of the individual’s being as well as the actions that unfold in situations, but Confucianism, due to being concerned with the spiritual dimension, remains committed to the original substance and knowing in the broader sense, while pragmatism, due to being rooted in experience and focusing on specific problems in situations, instrumentalizes concepts and simultaneously dissolves knowledge in practice. The perfection of life and the effectiveness of life both involve the significance of value, so Confucianism and pragmatism both focus on the evaluative dimension of knowing, but Confucianism incorporates cognition through the debate over the distinction between right and wrong, whereas pragmatism tends to eliminate cognition through evaluation

儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开

Confucianism and Pragmatism: The Intrinsic Philosophical Theme and Their Diverse Developments

计量

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开

English Abstract

Confucianism and Pragmatism: The Intrinsic Philosophical Theme and Their Diverse Developments

全文HTML

目录

儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开

Confucianism and Pragmatism: The Intrinsic Philosophical Theme and Their Diverse Developments

计量

文章相关

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

儒学与实用主义：内在哲学旨趣及其多样展开

English Abstract

Confucianism and Pragmatism: The Intrinsic Philosophical Theme and Their Diverse Developments

全文HTML

目录