Citation:
ZHANG Chixiang. Two Forms and Significance of Legal Academic Criticism[J]. Academic Monthly, 2024, 56(11): 103-115.
Two Forms and Significance of Legal Academic Criticism
-
Abstract
Academic criticism in law can be divided into two forms: internal criticism and external criticism.External criticism often fails to touch the real concerns of the object of criticism,easily ignores the theoretical presuppositions of the object of criticism,implies different concepts and discourse systems from the very beginning,or imposes tasks on the object of criticism that do not belong to the object of criticism in the first place.However,by highlighting the diversity of perspectives and objects of legal knowledge research,external criticism is able to point out the inherent defects of the object of criticism and the limits of its usefulness,prompting it to reflect explicitly on its own experience or theoretical presuppositions and to absorb the reasonable kernel of criticism.Internal criticism tends to neglect the reflection on common presuppositions,lose the concern for the “big problem”,or replace the problem study itself with doctrinal research.Compared with external criticism,internal criticism is more focused and can directly contribute to the evolution and development of theories and doctrines.In the current Chinese context,internal criticism should be the focus of constructing the knowledge system of Chinese law,but external criticism should also be allowed to play a complementary role.
-
-
References
-
Access
-
-
[1]
YANG Dian
, DONG Shuhao
. The Social Construction of Economic Value——Evidence from Financial Markets, with a Discussion on Building a Valuation System with Chinese Characteristics. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(1): 131-146.
-
[2]
GE Yonghai
, PAN Juqiang
. Why Regional Literary History in China Becomes a Discipline——Academic Origins,Historical Evolution,and Theoretical Construction. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(5): 159-173.
-
[3]
WANG Qi
. From Individual Experience to “Inner Experience”——Focusing on Bog om Adler. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(7): 32-40.
-
[4]
YU Jianxing
, LIU Yuxuan
. Beyond the Outside Observer: Repositioning the Social Sciences in the Era of Large Language Models. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(7): 77-89.
-
[5]
FENG Yurong
. “Illuminating Ancient Learning,Introducing New Knowledge”: Xin Yizong Bidu and the Shift in the Construction of Modern Traditional Chinese Medicine Knowledge. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(6): 180-190.
-
[6]
LIANG Tao
, XU Yuantong
. Human Mind,the Way Mind and the Counsels of Great Yu——An Academic Inquiry Based on the Misplaced Slips in Xunzi. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(5): 5-16.
-
[7]
HU Yiqing
, MA Zhihao
, ZONG Yixiang
. A Decade Review and Evaluation of the Development in the Discipline of Journalism and Communication (2009—2018)——Analysis Based on the Comprehensive Index of Humanities and Social Sciences. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(6): 206-216.
-
[8]
HE Jun
. Confucius's Paradigm Shaping of Chinese Philosophy. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(8): 56-69.
-
[9]
SHEN Yifei
. Theoretical Genealogies of the Emotional Economy and the Chinese Context. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(7): 129-142.
-
[10]
LI Ting
. From The Reproductive Institution to the Fertility Transition in Contemporary China. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(7): 143-156.
-
[11]
LIN Shangli
. China's Mission in Constructing Original Theories and Its Methodological Foundation. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(7): 5-11.
-
[12]
ZHAN Ling
. Adolescent Narratives and the Poetic Evolution of Contemporary Chinese Science Fiction. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(3): 166-175.
-
[13]
HE Yuhong
, ZHANG Chen
. The Transformation of Han Territories' Rule Strategy in the Jin Dynasty and the Identification of China. Academic Monthly,
2026, 58(1): 205-216.
-
-
沪公网安备 31010102003103号
DownLoad: